��Ļ��⣨¬�ǲ��˹��1919�꣩

��Ļ��

¬�ǲ��˹��

1919��

��¼��˵����ժ�ԡ��ʽ��¬�ɲ��˹��ѧ��ѡ��룬�ٻ��ճ��1998��棬��ֱ��

��޲��׼��Ļ��Ļ��⣬��ֹһ�εر��ĵؽ��ҳ��൱��ͬ��ĸ��һ��磬��һЩͷ�Ի��ˣ��˵��Ļ��ʵͬ�޲��׼��Ļ�û��κ��ϵ��κι��ʱ��ڲ��ܹ��²��ֵ�ʵ��Ļ��Ĺ۵㣬��ӹ�׵Ļ��壬��Ļ��Ĳ��˹̹��塣��Ļ�ֻ�ܺ��徭�ù�ͬʵ�֣��ǵ��Ǹ�ʱ��Ļ��Ѿ��ȫ��ܾ��޲��׼��ˣ��Ϊ��屾��ζ�Ž׼��ȻҲ��޲��׼��ڣ��Ļ�ֻ��ȫ��ġ�

��ɣ��ᷨ��Ϸ��˽��о��Ҫ��⡣

��޲��׼��ߡ��޲��׼��ʵ��Ϊ��ǲ��һ��͵ġ��һ��֮�ڷ��Ҫ��ѳ��˵��ʱ��ƶ��ڲ��ֵ��ر��ĸ��µ��ƶȣ��Ȼ�ǳ��ڵ��ˣ��Ϊ�޲��׼�ֻ��ȡ�ý׼�ʤ��֮��Ż��ᴴ��Ĺ۵��ȫ��ġ��޲��׼��ڴ��ʱ��ѹ�ȡ��Ѿ��ʶ��Լ��˼��ߵ�ʱ��ڴ��Լ��Ļ��ˡ�ʤ��֮��Ҳһ��޲��׼��ȫ��Ŀ��ٵصĴ��ߣ��ʤ��֮��޲��׼��ܵ��ģ��ڽ��ǿ��ŵĶ��Ȼʤ��޲��׼��Ź��Ȩ��һ��͹۵Ĺ۲�ң��ںܳ��ܳ��ʱ��ڻ��˵�޲��׼��һ��ǿ��ģ�һ��ܹ��Լ��ʤ��

��Ȼ��޲��׼��ڱ�ѹ�ȵ�λ��һ��׼��ʱ��Ļ��Ĵ��һ�ַ��ں�С�ķ�Χ�ڽ��е��޲��׼��Ϊһ��ϵġ��¼��ר��ߵ�ʱ��Ļ��Ĵ��һ�ַ��ڽϿ��ķ�Χ�ڽ��еģ��޲��׼��뿼�Ų��ݣ��޲��׼��Ϊ�׼��Ѳ��ڣ�ȫ��Ѿ��һ��Ͷ�ͳһ��ʱ��Ļ��Ե��ַ��ھ޴��ķ�Χ�ڽ��ˡ�

��ɳ�ʵ�Ȩ��ʹ��ʱ��Щ��޲��׼��Ļ�ͬ��ۡ�^[1]��֤��˵��޲��׼��ζ��ʱ�ڸ��û��޲��׼��Ļ��Ļ��޲��׼��Կ�ѧ��̬�ȣ��޲��׼��죬�޲��׼��ѧ��ƶ��׼��˵��һ��ݳޡ��һ��޲��׼��˵��û��Ҫ��ο�Ҫ��Ҳ��ܡ��Ȼ��ʲ��׼��Լ��ĸ��ʱ��Ļ��һ��޲��׼���ϵĽ׼��˵��޲��׼��Ļ��ʶ��ĸ��Щ��Ǽ��Ҫ��⣬�޲��׼��ܵز��ܽ��֮�Ժ��ڶ��Ӳ��⵱Ȼ��򲻵ü��Ľ��Ҿ��ȥ��ģ��᣻ǡǡ�෴��Ӧ��ǧ��ټƵ�ǿ��Ѹ߶ȳɳ��еĽ׼��ⷽ��

��ڣ��µ�˵��һ��棬�޲��׼��Ļ��滹��졣��ȫû��Լ��˼��ң��Լ��˼��Ϊ��١��ʣ��˭��˵�޲��׼��ѧ��Ȼ��ѧ��һЩ��ｫ��µġ�ʮ��Ҫ�Ĺ��ף��Щ��ȻҪ��޲��׼��ѧ�;��ѧ�ĸ��ۻ��Э��һ�£�Ȼ��޲��׼�˼��ⷽ��Ľ��١��޲��׼��е��ʲô�أ��ⷽ��ֻ��Ʒ�е�һЩ��ͷ��Ȼ��Щ��Ʒ��вŻ��޲��׼�ʫ��ı��ӣ��ǵ�ͷ��ϴ��׵罻�ӵ��ա�

��ɴ˿ɼ��޲��׼��Ϊ��޲��׼��Ļ��ʹ��ܴ��й��ӡ�ıȽ�ȷ��Ʒ��Ծ��ܿ��ξ��֮�ƣ��뵽Ϊδ��Ԥ��ġ��޴��ʤ��ǰ��ȥ��

��е��Ҳ��ʵ�֣��޲��׼��Ǿ��Լ��ϵ��ʲ��׼��ˮ��С�ʲ��׼��˼��ܹ��Ѹ��Ͷ�뵽��

��ͬʱ��޲��׼��ʷ��ȫ��Ļ��屦��ܲ��ö��˹��Һ��ӵ�е��Ӵ�Ŀ��кͽ�ѧ��

��ģ��Ӵ�ļ��壬��廨��ŵ��ټٵ��Ʒ��𲽵��ľ��ȥ��ʵ��ǻٵ��һ��޴��ͬʱ��Ҳ֪��Ϊר��ߵ��޲��׼��Ϊ��˹��Ȩ��޲��׼��񡣱��ÿ�ѧԺ��ѧ��ݡ�ʵ��ҡ��ѧ��Ժ��ֻᡢչ��ᣬ�ȵȣ��ȵȡ�

��ֹͣ��ǵĻ��ɶ��֮��˵��ǲ��ǵĽ׼����Ǿ��Ķ��֮�٣��ֻҪ�Ѷ��һ��ֹ�Դ��Ǿͻ�ðʹ��ڰ��Σ�ա�

��һ��ʲ��׼�֮�ֻ��ʲ��׼�֪ʶ��֮�ֵ�ȼ�ķ��壬��ҲҪ��ˣ��Щ���඼�ܻ谵��Ϊ��࣬��ڵ��ⲻ��Ҫ��Ϩ�𣬶��Ҫ�跨ʹ��Ǹ��ӹ��취��ⷽ��Ϊ�Ѻ��κ��Թ��߶��е��ۣ��ı��ʹ��Ϊ��Ļ��Ĺ��ߡ�

��⣬�޲��׼��Ȩ��̽��Լ��صĵ�·��ÿ�ѧԺ�ʹ�ѧ��һ��м�ֵ�Ķ��ʹ��µ��ʽ�»��޲��׼��ܹ��ν��Լ��Ĵ�ѧ��Ϊ��ڽ��Ⱥ��Ի�з��ã��Щ��ѧ�Ĺ�ģĿǰ��̫С��Ҳ̫��ǣ��Ϊδ��Ļ��ʵ��Ƿǳ��Ҫ�ģ��ά��ΪȺ�ڻ�ȡ֪ʶ�ͼ��ܵĶ��˵��Ҳ�Ƿǳ��Ҫ�Ļ��⻹Ҫ��𣿰Ѿɵ��Ļ��ͳͳ��٣��Щ��еĽṹ��ĳ��ð�յĸĸ�ܹ��̫ðʧ��ͬʱ��ÿ��ֶ��޲��׼��뷽�跨ʹ�Լ��˽��Ļ��һ�кõĶ��֪�ö��Ƿǳ��ǳ�֮��ġ��Ǳ��ֳ��ôŨ��Ȥ��

��뿴�޲��ĳɹ��ʲô��ǵļ��Ȥζ��ȷ�ģ��Ȼ��˳��ø��ָ��޳��Ի��˵�˵��ǣ�һЩ��ŵ��Ҳ��޳��ĵ��ϵ��л��ಽ��ʰ��ۣ��޲��׼�һ��ı��硢ϲ��Ϻõĸ�磬��ܸо��ó��֮��ȫ��졣��Ҿ�Ժ��޲��߳��ԭ�˵ø��ž�Ժ��ڼ��о��ǰ��Ϸ��ɽ��Ժ��ۿ��Ƕ��Ȳʵ��Ρ�С��Ժ��Ҫ�ǹ��ˡ�^[2]

��Ƿ��޲��׼��ģ��Ǽ��ո߳��˽⣬Ҳ��ɫɫ��δ��ɷ��ӡ��󴵴��ޡ��Ŀ��̽��޲��׼��ӭ��Щδ��ɷ��Ϸ��Ϊƣ��ʲ��߸�Щ��߰˲۵Ķ��û�д��κ��Ķ��

��ͬʱ��޲��׼�Ѱ��Լ��صģ�ͬ��֪ʶ��Ѱ��ĵ�·δ��һ�µĵ�·��

��֪ʶ��Ϊ�޲��׼��ϵ�ѧУ��ʶ��صĶ��Щ��걾��ණ��ҲҪ��޲��׼�ѧϰ��ֻ��֪ʶ��Ӳ��ܹ��һ��Ļ��ã�^[3]��ܹ��ĸ��Ը��׼��Сѧ��Ļ��

��Ҿٵ��һ��Ե��ӣ��ǰϷ����ʵ��Ļ��򵽴��ܿ��

��ˣ��֣��ضԴ��Ծ��Ļ��λ��һ��飬ʹ��Ƿ��ܹ�Ϊ��ܣ��м�ĵжԷ��ӻ��޲��׼��õĶ��ȥ��𲽳�ʵ��µ��ݣ��ⲻ��Ҫ��ƻ��Ͳ��Ҫ�ļ��

��ίԱ��ⷽ��߹�ȥ��ˣ��Ȼ��ˣ�ֻҪ�ⷽ��쵼��^[4]

��˵��ϲ��˹��ϲ��ԥ��Ϥ��ίԱ����⣬δ��ⷽ��ǣ��ҵ��ĵĵ��ѧУ��Щ�ط��ǲ��Щ̫��ð��ˡ��˵��Һ��ͬ־�ǡ��ҵ�ͬ�º��֡��Ҫ��ʵ��̬�ȡ��׷��ͳһ�Ͷ��ۺϼ��ѧУ��棬��ɣ��ǹ��˶�רҵ��ѧУ��˺��^[5]

��ⷽ�滹��Ծٳ�һЩ��Ͳ��صļ��ӣ��ǻ�е�ؼӿ��ɳ��̵��һ��Ļ��

��˵һ�飬��ⷽ�棬��Ǹ��Ǽ��ð��ж��ٻ��Ҳ��ж��ٻ��ǽ�ȫ��ú͸��Ǵӹ�ȥ�̳��Ļ��ע��˺��ǣ��Ҫ��ñ��в��Ķ��ȡ��ǵ�ʱ��ֹͣ��ǵĻ��ǣ�ͬ��Ҳ��ȫ��ά��޲��׼��ȫ��Լ��Ļ��Ȩ��Ƕ��ά��ҵģ��Եġ��޲��׼��һ��ܹ��۵Ķ��ɣ��޲��׼��̽��µ��ʽ��ڿ�ѧ��Ѱ��µķ��ɡ�

��Ҳ��޲��׼��Ļ�Э�Ტ��˽��Լ��Ҳ��ʱ��ͬ��ά��ƽ�еĹ��ʲô��ϵ��ά��֮��Ĺ�ϵ��ǳ��ң��ǲ��ں��໥֮��Ħ��Ҫ֪��˭��뵽Ӧ�ô��ʲô��λ��˵��ӹ��񾭼�ίԱ��ʳίԱ��ȡ��һ��أ��޲��׼��Ļ�Э��ȫ��صĵ�λ��ȫ֧��޲��׼��Ļ�Э��ں��ܹ㷺��Ȩ��^[6]

��Ҹе��˵��ǣ��һ�˶��޲��׼��ʣ��һЩ֪ʶ��ͬ־��ڰ��һ�˶��Ƕ��ð��Լ��˼��Լ��Ȥζǿ�Ӹ��Щ��֯�ж�ôΣ�գ��Щͬ־ֻ��Ϊδ��Ĵ��ɨ��·��֡�

��ϣ��ڵ�һƪ��в��Ĺ��ڴ��Ļ��ĳ��롣

��һ��޵Ĺ��ַǳ��ܣ��Ǳ��ά��Ļ��ĵ�·�ϣ��޲��׼�̽��ĵ�·�ϡ�

��Ȼ��Һ�Ը��ǰ��в��ϵĻ��Ŭ��Ļ��ӱ��ʱ��Ǹ�ʲô��ӡ��⣬��ŵ��ͬ־��ܱ��뷨��^[7]��¾��ϣ��Ƕ��Щ��Ȥ��ر�Ӧ��ȥ��һ��һƪ��ҽ��̸��Լ��Ŀ��^[8]

^[1] ¬�ǲ��˹��ָ�Լ��ġ��޲��׼��ѧ��򡷣�1914��һ�ġ�
��1913�꣬��ǵĳ�ϼ��־��4��5�ڷ��A.��¡��ʡ��û��ѧ��û��ѧ����ص��6�ڡ��ʡ��û��ѧ��û��ѧ���޲��׼��Ļ��ı��磩��˹��޲��׼��ѧ�ܷ��ڵ��ۡ��μ��۵��B.��򣨱��B.��ŵ��¡��޲��׼��Ļ��⡷�ء��ǵĳ�ϼ��1913��10��11�ڣ��.��дĻ�(��¡��޲��׼��Ļ��ء��ǵĳ�ϼ��1914��1�ڣ��.��ȿƷ��¡��빤�˽׼��̬�ȡ��ء��ǵĳ�ϼ��1914��3�ڣ��ˡ��βμ��ۡ��ء��ǵĳ�ϼ��1913��10��11�ڣ�1914��2��3��7-9�ڡ�
��¬�ǲ��˹��ԡ��޲��׼��ѧ��Ͳ��һ�Ĳμ��ۣ��ʹ��μ��۵��һ��˲��Ĺ۵㡣

^[2] ��д��1918�꣬��Ժ��һֱ��Ϊ��ܣ��Ȼ��¬�ǲ��˹��1923��ע��ԭ��

^[3] ��·��Щʱ�򣬶��Ҳ��ڿ�ͷ�ϣ��ſɷ�˹��С��֮��Ϊ��¬�ǲ��˹��1923��ע��ԭ��

^[4] ��ȥ�ˣ��Ȼ��Ϊ��¬�ǲ��˹��1923��ע��ԭ��

^[5] ��˹��ͳһ�Ͷ�ѧУ�涨��¬�ǲ��˹��Ϊ�׵Ĺ��Ҽ��ίԱ��ƶ��ģ�1918��10��ȫ��ִ��ίԱ��䲼��ȫ��ִ��ίԱ�ṫ��1918��10��16�գ��225�ţ��涨ǿ��Ͷ�ѧУ��ѧϰ��ͨ��ۺϼ��ʡ��ڹ��ڰ˴δ��ᣨ1919��3�£��ͨ��ĵ��̸��˶��17��ǰ�ĺ��һ��ʵ��ѡ��ͨ��ۺϼ��Լ��17��ߵ�רҵ��⣨��չ��δ��ᡢ��顢��ȫ��ľ��;��7�棬��1��Ī˹�ƣ�1953�꣬��419-420ҳ��

^[6] ��һ��ڻ��ȫ֧�֣�¬�ǲ��˹��1923��ע��ԭ��

^[7] A.A.��ŵ��ŵ��˹��ı��1873-1928��Ψ��ѧ�ң��λ�ң��ѧ�ң��ң��޲��׼��Ļ�Э��˼��֮һ��д��޲��׼��Ļ��ѧ�빤�˽׼��1918��˽׼��չ�е��޲��׼��Ļ��ء��1920��ȣ��ڡ��޲��׼��Ļ��һ�飬Ī˹��-��գ�1924�꣩��޲��׼��Ļ�Э��ġ��޲��׼��޲��׼��ѧ��޲��׼��Ļ��۵Ĵ��ߣ��Щ��ڡ�ʵ��ҡ��ģ��ġ��Լ��ġ�Ψ��;��塷һ��ĵڶ��У��Ϊ��¼��B.��˹��¡��֤Ψ��ͽ��ѧ��˽�ȥ��д��ŷ��֤��ŵ��޲��׼��Ļ��Ļ��¡��ʲ��׼��ĺͷ��Ĺ۵㡣��

^[8] ��һ�㣬¬�ǲ��˹��ڡ��޲��׼��ѧԭ��һ��ϸ��

��л �� ¼�뼰У��